March 29th, 2010 • 17:03
Why Are Some Women Crazy About Breast-feeding Their Children?
I understand that is is better for both the mother and the baby. I’m even willing to admit tha if I had kids, I’d probably do it as well. What I don’t understand are the people who get mad at women who feed their children baby formula. My mom used baby formula because she worked, and she didn’t want it to be too difficult for my au pear / babysitter to care for me. Also, baby formula keeps babies full longer,so you aren’t constantly breastfeeding the kid.
I’m just wondering why some people go crazy about it… my mom got some of that. Even my neighbor who did both got it too. o__o
Mar 29th 2010 • 18:03
by Shayla
i breast and formula feed my son..they say that breastmilk gives the baby more vitamins, its easier to digest, they get less gas which makes them less likely to get colic, and it boosts their immune system. i do think that breastfeeding is better simply because its free and its better for them and you dont have to get out of bed in the middle of the night to warm up a bottle, all you gotta do is grab the baby and latch him on. BUT the formulas nowadays have the same nutrients and everything that breastmilk does and thats why i also give my son formula. besides, if i dont breastfeed EVERYTIME he is hungry and dont pump like every 2-3 hours i dont produce enough..plus i really dont want to pop my boob out in public or in front of anyone who isnt my boyfriend so thats another reason why i formula feed most of the time…idk i guess it depends on the person
but yea i cant stand it when doctors and nutritionist and certain people get so anal about people who give their kids formula or stop breastfeeding…like the girl a few answers above me said ‘its my baby’ **** if i dont want to breastfeed im not going to and i really dont want to hear nobody bitching at me..my boyfriends mom is very anal about me breastfeeding and she always has an attitude when i dont do it as often as she likes and it really pissed me off
Mar 29th 2010 • 19:03
by Ivy's Having Twins!
I think part of it is because it is much more difficult in the beginning to breast-feed. I am currently breastfeeding twins, and have many strong reasons for doing so, but for others looking down on formula feeding may be part of their motivation to continue breastfeeding. I don’t care if others give formula, but no way in hell am I going to do it. And I have to feel strongly about it to put up with people like my mom telling me “go back to bed, go back to bed, just go back to bed” when I get up to breastfeed and she wants to give them formula.
I think the formula feeders we know give us the breastfeeders hell about breastfeeding too though. At least my mom isn’t very supportive of it. She says she supports it, then says things like “you’ll have to stop when you get sore”, “you better have formula on hand for when you need it”, “you need to sleep instead of breastfeed every 3 hours or you’ll get depressed and very fat”, “your cousins couldn’t do it”, and “I think you’re only breastfeeding because you don’t want to pay for formula”. Also breastfeeding in the same room as my dad really bothered him even though I was covered by a receiving blanket.
So it does go both ways.
I know one of the things that does drive breastfeeders nuts is when formula feeders give false excuses for formula feeding. Like they don’t produce enough. It is supply and demand, and the act of giving formula makes it so you don’t have enough supply. The only way that makes sense is if the person is pumping / nursing for more than 30 minutes x 12 times a day and their child is still losing weight. If you are doing that then you truly are simply unable to make enough. Sometimes people want their babies fatter / more content then nature makes them. Thus they think they don’t make enough, when they really do.
I am breastfeeding 10 hours a day. Twins, 30 minutes each every 2 hours, 3 hours during my 3 daily sleep sessions. I do occasionally give formula when one has been feeding for 45 minute sessions more than 3 times in a row. I would eventually make enough to cover this, but I use the formula then for conveinience. I have a double electric pump now though, so will simply add in pumping sessions and ditch formula now.
Mar 29th 2010 • 19:03
by Maggie
I understand that is is better for both the mother and the baby. I’m even willing to admit tha if I had kids, I’d probably do it as well. What I don’t understand are the people who get mad at women who feed their children baby formula. My mom used baby formula because she worked, and she didn’t want it to be too difficult for my au pear / babysitter to care for me. Also, baby formula keeps babies full longer,so you aren’t constantly breastfeeding the kid.
I’m just wondering why some people go crazy about it… my mom got some of that. Even my neighbor who did both got it too. o__o
Mar 29th 2010 • 21:03
by fwipper
I think what is frustrating is that a lot of people don’t breastfeed just because it seems too hard and they don’t get support. Baby formula “keeping them full for longer” is one of those myths that get circulated so that people think they are depriving their babies, or they will get more sleep if they formula feed (definitely not true with my kids!). Baby formula is just more difficult for baby to digest, it doesn’t keep them fuller for longer, tho it is much easier to overfeed a formula fed baby.
I guess maybe they go crazy because some breastfeeding advocates see formula feeding as not persevering enough with BF?? – personally I don’t think it really matters too much how the baby gets their food as long as both mum and baby are happy and healthy.
But I do think there is a lack of support for breastfeeding mothers, who give up or don’t try because of it. Lots of mothers give up for the “work” reason – where is is still possible to BF and work with the right support in the workplace and home. Just as easy for a caregiver to give breastmilk in a bottle as it is to give formula but not many employers are very supportive of mothers pumping at work. Breastmilk is free, and with the melamine formula tragedy in china last year it is possible could be a safer choice.
I guess I think that everybody should have the support to be able to make the choice. Often breastfeeding, while the better choice nutritionally, is the more difficult choice logistically especially if working.
I don’t think getting angry at BF or formula feeders serves any purpose at all.
Mar 29th 2010 • 21:03
by Mommy to Maddox, Colton and Liam
Cuz people like to be judgmental. I breastfed my older son for 2 months and then started some formula, by 6 months old he was on all formula (he stopped wanting to breastfed). I am now currently breastfeeding my twins who are nearly 4 months old and i haven’t introduced formula and don’t plan too, unless absolutely necessary. But i don’t judge what other women do with their babies as it’s not my place, and i hate when people do that, some people just need to learn to mind their own darn business.
Hope this helps,
Mar 29th 2010 • 21:03
by celestia
The facts about breastfeeding make a lot of women passionate. So passionate about the greater good of a baby getting these benefits that they would push their views about it onto anyone. No boundaries, being absolutely annoying, but not caring about it because if they can convince that person to breastfeed, they were successful. It’s not about people liking you. It’s about hoping they will do this for their baby, because it would be worth it. The benefits are definitely something to be crazy about, and they outweigh any benefits of formula to such a degree that they are virtually incomparable. I know you’re biased because your mother did it, and you’re naturally defensive. And that’s okay. Breastfeeding doesn’t work out for everyone. Sometimes it’s just not right for a particular mother. You’re being defensive of invisible opposition here. No one is going to condemn a formula feeding mother to hell. No one has the right to judge anyone else’s circumstances. But please do not call those who breastfeed crazy. It’s just not nice.
Mar 29th 2010 • 21:03
by Niagara
I don;t quite understand it myself. Perhaps it is the same reason that some formula feeding moms are so anti-breastfeeding.
Mar 29th 2010 • 22:03
by made you look is due Oct 3rd
I don’t think the problem is that they use formula. Formula was intended for mothers who can’t breast feed or as a plan b. Now, it’s being used because the mom simply doesn’t want to or is too lazy. I mean it’s fine if you psychically can’t or have VERY bad memories such as child molestation or something which I have heard about sometimes deters mothers from breastfeeding but, doing it simply for your connivance is stupid for lack of better words.
What I like to see from mom’s is some effort. Try it out. If you only do it for a month or two so be it at least you TRYED. I pumped for 15 months which wasn’t the easiest thing but, I did it for the overall health of my baby. I know whats in my breast milk, that there are 0 preservatives, it has omegas, and etc.
BTW, Formula does not keep babies full longer. Babies would loose weight if that was the case.
ETA: When it comes down to it, it’s their bodies. Just like abortion they can do what THEY want. With a self absorbed culture we live in everything is MY BABY, MY DECISION, MY PARENTING, and etc. I believe it takes a village to raise a child, opinions and all. Don’t get me wronge I don’t see much wrong with formula but, I still think overall it should be a second choice.
Mar 29th 2010 • 22:03
by Carly *Jazlynn's Mommy*
Well some people just want what’s best for the child. Some people (myself included) do a lot of research in order to give our children the very best we possibly can. Some of us have certain things we are dead set on, and that’s just how it is, for any number of reasons. Breastfeeding is the best option, hands down, there is no denying that. Some people choose to formula feed for all kinds of reasons, and that is ok, but for someone who took the time to research all the benefits, etc., they are going to tell a new mother what they know. Not pushing them to do it, not saying formula feeding is wrong, but to give someone an informative answer. I wish i would have breastfed my daughter longer. There are people on here that breastfeed until their children are 2+ and looking back, i would like to have done that, but i honestly didn’t do enough research. So i would have loved for someone to convince me to continue breastfeeding when i decided to stop. So i don’t think it’s mothers being overly pushy, but more that they are passionate about what they have learned and want to inform other mothers, and i can agree with that. I do the same with other topics.
Mar 29th 2010 • 22:03
by ☆**•¸She's Here!!¸•**☆
I know what you mean. I breastfeed AND formula feed my 2 month old because I don’t produce enough milk.. I went to several lactation nurses and talked to two pediatricians and my regular OB and cannot get my supply up.. with this said in most my questions I still get attacked for not solely breastfeeding it is so ridicules. I think moms in general think they know what is not only best for their baby but because they are moms they know what is best for Other peoples babies to. I understand why they feel so strongly but in the end it is still My baby My rules.
Mar 29th 2010 • 23:03
by GranolaM
Some people are just crazy about their kids and want the best for them.
Personally, I don’t want to pay good money to buy a substitute for the real thing.
Mar 30th 2010 • 00:03
by The All Seeing Eye
some people are just CRAZY
now in a crazy persons life, at some point, breastfeeding is a thing to be crazy about, so they just continue being crazy